On Monday, October 18, 1880, the famed freethought orator Robert Green Ingersoll delivered a political speech supporting the campaign of James A. Garfield, who would become the twentieth president of the United States. This oration took place at Sink's Opera House on 104 South Dominick Street, an address that no longer exists.
Ingersoll returned to Sink's Opera House on Tuesday, January 20, 1885, where he delivered his popular but controversial speech about religious matters, "Orthodoxy." So far as is known, that was Ingersoll's final visit to Rome, New York.
The Building and Site. Sink's Opera House stood on a part of East Dominick Street built on land that had formerly been part of Fort Stanwix. It was built by Andrew J. Sink and opened on the night of September 27, 1869. Strictly speaking, Sink's was a hall, not an opera house; its floor was flat rather than sloped, and movable benches were used for seating. Yet it was Rome's first "proper stage" and became a beloved center for community gatherings as well as cultural events.
Out-competed by the Washington Street Opera House, which was some twenty years newer, Sink's ceased operations as an auditorium in 1902. Professor Seagar operated a dancing academy in the building until June 27, 1904, when the structure burned down in a catastrophic fire that also claimed adjacent buildings and injured numerous firefighters. In addition, several community organizations that had met at the opera house for decades lost all their records.
It was decided not to rebuild the opera house. Various businesses moved onto the parcel, which soon became known as the Larkin Block. As it happens, the three-story Larkin Block also burned down on March 21, 1940. In contrast to the Opera House fire, the Larkin fire caused few injuries and did not damage adjacent structures.
When the National Park Service reconstructed Fort Stanwix in the 1970s, the block of Dominick Street on which Sink's Opera House had stood was demapped and made part of the fort's expanded grounds. West Dominick Street now ends at James Street; on the other side of the fort complex, East Dominick Street ends at Highway 46. The actual location of Sink's Opera House lies near the Marinus Willett Visitor Center on the Fort property (built in 2005).
Thanks to Arthur L. Simmons III, executive director of the Rome Historical Society, for research assistance.