On October 21, 1835, a statewide meeting was held in Utica for the purpose of reconstituting a previously dormant New York State anti-slavery society. At this time anti-slavery and abolitionism were radical and widely unpopular stances, even in the north. Community resistance had prevented the meeting from being held in a public building, so the site was shifted to the Second Presbyterian Church on the southeast corner of Bleecker and Charlotte Streets.
Philanthropist Gerrit Smith attended the meeting almost out of curiosity. Though he opposed slavery, he was not an "immediatist," one who called for slavery’s immediate abolition. Instead he favored colonization—the repatriation of black slaves to Africa—a view then losing favor among serious reformers.
The October 21 meeting began at 10:00 a.m., with an attendance estimated at from six hundred to one thousand persons from across New York State. The meeting had not progressed far in its agenda when a crowd of some three hundred locals gathered outside, shouting invective and threatening to storm the church. Just when a riot seemed inevitable, Smith urged that the meeting reconvene in his home town of Peterboro, twenty-seven miles southwest of Utica, where the delegates’ safety could be guaranteed. Some three to six hundred delegates made their way to Peterboro, where on October 22, the first meeting of the New York Anti-Slavery Society was completed.
This experience profoundly changed Smith’s views. By the end of the Peterboro meeting he had abandoned his support of colonization and come out as an immediatist abolitionist. He went on to become one of abolition’s most zealous advocates and without doubt was the movement’s most generous supporter. And it all began at the corner of Bleecker and Charlotte Street.
Second Presbyterian Church was dedicated in 1826. The congregation broke up in 1840. A Congregationalist group hired the church in 1841 and held services there for about three years. The building was briefly empty until a new Presbyterian congregation occupied it for about two years. In 1845, a Baptist congregation claimed the building, and Bleecker Street Baptist Church operated until 1887. In that year, the Baptist congregation dissolved and the church was sold. It is thought that the building was razed shortly thereafter.