Gerrit Smith (1797–1874) was a free thinker, but not a "freethinker" in the narrower sense of one who rejected Christianity. He remained a Christian, albeit a radical one, throughout his life. But in every other way, Smith exemplified the radical reform impulse and the astonishing cross-fertilization of causes and people that distinguishes the Freethought Trail.
Smith was pre-Civil War America’s foremost philanthropist and reformer. He became a seminal figure in the abolition movement, a major participant in the Underground Railroad, and a significant figure in the woman's suffrage movement, some of whose leading figures were closely associated with him. (Nineteenth-century practice was to use the singular, woman's, when referring to women as a class; later practice was to use the plural, women's.) In addition, he took a strong interest in the dress reform movement of the 1850s, which sought more practical and healthful clothing for women. His daughter, Elizabeth Smith Miller, is credited with developing dress reform’s signature garment: the Bloomer costume, consisting of Turkish-style pantaloons over a mid-length skirt.
Smith was also the prototype for a conspicuous American stereotype, the child of great wealth who takes up liberal causes. His father, Peter Smith, made a fortune in the fur trade as a partner to John Jacob Astor (1763–1848) and established the village of Peterboro, New York, in 1795, naming it for himself. In 1804, he established the homestead that would become the Gerrit Smith Estate.
Gerrit Smith greatly increased his inherited fortune through his own business acumen. He built a mansion and other buildings on the homestead site, married Ann Carroll Fitzhugh (1805–1875), and began devoting his energy and wealth to reform causes of the day, including abolition, temperance, and woman's suffrage. A stationmaster on the Underground Railroad, he lodged hundreds of fugitive slaves, frequently purchasing their freedom, facilitating their passage to Canada utilizing his large holdings in the Lake Ontario port city of Oswego, or assisting them in settling in New York State. His home became a salon that leading reformers, politicians, and businesspeople visited to discuss pressing issues.
On October 21, 1835, Smith attended the inaugural meeting of the reconstituted New York State Anti-slavery Society at Utica’s Second Presbyterian Church. The meeting was disrupted by a mob. Smith invited all of the delegates to travel to Peterboro that night and complete their meeting there the next day. Three to six hundred of them did so. On October 22, New York’s first public antislavery meeting was completed at Peterboro’s Presbyterian Church; the experience prompted Smith to abandon his former advocacy of colonization—the repatriation of enslaved blacks to Africa—and take up "immediatism," the demand for slavery to be abolished immediately. The Peterboro meeting site is now home to the National Abolition Hall of Fame.
In October 1845, Smith traveled to Boston and addressed a major regional antislavery convention. His lecture was so well regarded that on the spot he was invited to deliver it on five more occasions.
Politics. In 1840, Smith helped organize the Liberty Party, the first openly abolitionist political party. In February 1842, he hosted a New York State Liberty Party convention at his mansion in Peterboro. Beginning in 1845, the Liberty Party became divided over whether or not to take reformist positions on issues other than slavery. Smith was on the side of those who preferred to maintain the party's purity of focus. Smith, Frederick Douglass, and others founded the Liberty League, originally intended as a special interest group within the Liberty Party. At a meeting in Macedon Lock (modern-day Macedon) in June 1847, the Liberty League reconstituted itself as a political party in its own right.
Overall, Smith would be nominated for president of the United States four times by various parties, and for governor of New York once.
By the 1848 presidential campaign, the Liberty Party had been significantly weakened, both by its internal divisions and by the rise of the Free Soil movement, a loose but powerful coalition that had among its goals to ensure that newly acquired U.S. states and territories were free, not slave. It is estimated that 80 percent of New Yorkers who had voted Liberty in 1844 transferred their loyalty to Free Soil; Smith's Liberal League remained as a home for purists still committed to a single-issue antislavery party. But Smith became dissatisfied with it, and in June 1848, he founded yet another abolition party, the National Liberty Party, out of the Liberal League. Even so, Smith was nominated as the Liberty Party's presidential candidate; his acceptance speech at the party’s convention in Buffalo, New York, included a bold demand for universal suffrage, explicitly encompassing black and white, male and female. This was an audacious position for an antislavery activist of the time. Smith became the 1848 presidential nominee of three small abolitionist parties: the Liberty League, the National Liberty Party, and the National Reform Association (the only party of the three which Smith did not help organize, and not to be confused with the later National Reform Association [founded 1864] that sought to add Christian language to the U. S. Constitution).
By 1852, the Liberty Party was moribund. The National Liberty Party was tiny and without influence outside New York State. Nonetheless, Smith was again nominated for the presidency at the National Liberty Party's 1852 convention in Oswego. The nomination was of so little importance to him that he did not campaign for president. Instead, a complex series of developments led to his election to the U.S. House of Representatives on an independent ticket. He found serving in Congress disagreeable, it being difficult to interest other legislators in his moralistic calls for reform. He resigned his seat halfway through his term, in August 1854. Despairing of achieving social change through participation in government, he thereafter focused on philanthropy and private organizing—though he did participate in a last-ditch 1855 effort to found still another party, the Radical Abolition Party, at a convention held at Syracuse's City Hall. Little came of this initiative.
Philanthropy. Smith generously supported all the causes he believed in. He built the nation’s first temperance hotel (no alcohol served) at Peterboro and provided lavish support for the abolition movement, the Underground Railroad, and the woman’s movement. It is believed that he funded the first dress reform convention, held in January 1857 in Canastota, just down the road from Peterboro. He was one of the “Secret Six” Northern philanthropists who funded John Brown’s raid on Harper’s Ferry, West Virginia, which helped spark the Civil War. (He became so distraught over the raid’s outcome that he suffered a brief nervous breakdown; it remained controversial throughout his life how much he had known regarding Brown’s plans for an armed slave revolt.)
It is estimated that during his life, Mr. and Mrs. Smith donated some eight million dollars (at current values, more than $250 million) to charitable causes. His Peterboro estate became such a center for abolition organizing that African American abolitionist Henry Highland Garnet wrote: “There are yet two places where slaveholders cannot come, Heaven and Peterboro.” Frederick Douglass published this comment on the front page of his Rochester-based abolition paperThe North Star on December 8, 1848. (Douglass would later dedicate his second autobiography, My Bondage and My Freedom (1855), to Smith.)
Garnet did not exaggerate. Smith spent heavily on flooding the Peterboro area with abolitionist literature and speakers, hoping to demonstrate how profound the impact of intense local campaigning could be. During a single week in November 1843, the seven agents Smith employed in Madison County (where Peterboro is located) conducted an astonishing forty-three antislavery meetings. Another measure of Smith's success was that Madison County supported antislavery candidates, whenever on the ballot, by larger margins than anywhere else in the country. To Smith's disappointment, abolitionists in other areas (none of whom, to be fair, possessed anywhere near his financial resources) failed to follow his lead.
Woman's Rights and Nonpolitical Abolition Protests. On August 2, 1848, two weeks after the woman's rights movement was launched at Seneca Falls, New York, a follow-on woman's rights convention was held in Rochester. Smith was unable to attend but sent a letter expressing his support, which was read out before the convention.
In August 1850, he helped to organize a protest convention in Cazenovia to oppose the Fugitive Slave Law of 1850, which empowered the federal government to capture escaped slaves even in free states and obliged free-state residents to cooperate with apprehension efforts. (Protests notwithstanding, the U.S. Congress passed the measure on September 18 as part of the Compromise of 1850.)
In October 1851, Smith exhorted Syracuse-area abolitionists to defy the new law. On the evening of October 1, reformers and activists broke down the door of a police station to free William "Jerry" Henry, an escaped slave being held pending his forcible return to Missouri. The raid, known as the Jerry Rescue, was successful. "Jerry" escaped to freedom in Canada within a few days; the event galvanized abolitionists nationwide. Afterward, Smith lauded the rescue as the epitome of abolitionist principles in action, urging his colleagues to operate always at the "Jerry Level." He would later grow disillusioned when this high degree of abolitionist fervor was not maintained.
Dress Reform. On January 7–8, 1857, Smith attended the first significant dress reform convention, held at Canastota, just a few miles north of Peterboro. In all likelihood, Smith paid the costs of the event. Attendees included Mary Edwards Walker of Oswego, who would become the only woman to receive the Medal of Honor and would adopt radical reform dress for the rest of her life.
So adamant was Smith in his belief that dress reform alone would improve the condition of women that his daughter Elizabeth Smith Miller felt compelled to continue wearing the Bloomer costume for several years after other suffragists abandoned the fashion.
Family Links. Smith’s personal connections were as impressive as his activism. He was cousin to the future Elizabeth Cady Stanton, who met her future husband Henry Brewster Stanton at a social event at Smith’s mansion. His daughter Elizabeth (Smith Miller) at one time lived across the town green from her father’s estate and became a suffragist and a philanthropist in her own right. Her role in developing the Bloomer costume (named for its most conspicuous promoter, Seneca Falls activist Amelia Bloomer) has already been mentioned.
Smith's Physical Legacy. The Smith mansion burned down in 1936. The Gerrit Smith Estate was declared a National Historic Landmark in 2001. The former Peterboro Presbyterian Church was placed on the National Register of Historic Places in 1994; in 2004, it became the home of the National Abolition Hall of Fame.