Once Rochester’s premier lecture hall, the site of addresses by such luminaries as abolitionists Susan B. Anthony and William Lloyd Garrison, Ralph Waldo Emerson, Horace Greeley, and many others.
The building was constructed in 1849 on Exchange Place (later Corinthian Street) behind the Reynolds Arcade, Rochester’s first truly great commercial building. The architect was Henry Searle; the owner was the Rochester Athenaeum and Mechanics Association, led by Arcade owner William A. Reynolds. Originally the building was to be called the Athenaeum, named for the 1829 lecture hall it would replace. Inspired by the Corinthian columns adorning its stage, Reynolds chose instead to dub it Corinthian Hall.
During its first year, the Hall hosted the notorious Fox Sisters, who claimed to speak with "the spirits" by means of mysterious rapping sounds (which, it was later discovered, they actually produced by flexing joints in their toes). A Corinthian Hall appearance on November 14, 1849, was the Fox Sisters' first "demonstration" before a paying audience, and led directly to the establishment of the religion of Spiritualism.
Corinthian Hall was the site of Frederick Douglass’s famous July 5, 1852, "Fifth of July" speech condemning the fraud of celebrating the Fourth of July as a festival of freedom for all while the nation still held slaves. (Emancipation of slaves in New York—which occurred on July 4, 1827—was traditionally celebrated on July 5 so as not to conflict with Independence Day observances.)
On February 13–14, 1857, Corinthian Hall was the site of an anti-slavery convention. Hezekiah Joslyn (father of woman’s rights [nineteenth-century practice was to use the singular, woman's; later practice was to use the plural, women's] advocate Matilda Joslyn Gage), served as the convention’s vice president. Speakers included William Lloyd Garrison, Frederick Douglass, and Susan B. Anthony.
During 1859, Susan B. Anthony attempted to establish a Free Church in Rochester, renting Corinthian Hall for a series of Sunday evening lectures. Anthony biographer Ida Husted Harper said Anthony was inspired by the similar church launched in Boston by the liberal Congregationalist reformer Theodore Parker, "where no doctrines should be preached and all should be welcome." Several lectures were held, always at a financial loss, and ultimately the plan had to be abandoned.
On December 2, 1859, the day of John Brown’s execution, Susan B. Anthony organized and presided over a 300-person “meeting of mourning and eulogy” at Corinthian Hall.
On October 26, 1877, Corinthian Hall was the site of the first annual convention of the National Liberal League, the period’s most prominent national freethought organization. On July 19, 1878, it hosted a conference of the National Woman Suffrage Association organized by Amy Post.
The building was remodeled in 1879 and was thereafter known as the Academy of Music.
In 1883, the building was the site of a convention of the New York State Freethinkers Association that began on August 29. Rochester freethinker Charles B. Reynolds, whom Robert Green Ingersoll would famously defend against blasphemy charges three years later, delivered a eulogy for atheist publisher D. M. Bennett. On September 1, religious skeptic John E. Remsburg delivered an address titled "False Claims."
In addition, agnostic orator Robert Green Ingersoll spoke at this site on at least three occasions: on January 11, 1878, when he delivered his lecture "Liberty"; on February 21, 1878, when he delivered his lecture "Individuality"; and on January 26, 1885, when he delivered his lecture "Which Way?"
Destroyed in an 1898 fire, the building was rebuilt in 1904 as the Corinthian Theater. It closed in 1928 and was razed the following year. Its site is now occupied by a dreary parking structure. Corinthian Street was reduced to its present stature by construction of the Midtown Plaza project in 1962.